Abstract  We propose a consistency test for some recent X-ray gas mass fraction (fgas) measurements in galaxy clusters, using the cosmic distance-duality relation, ηtheory = DL (1 + z)−2 /DA, with luminosity distance (DL) data from the Union2 compilation of type Ia supernovae. We set ηtheory ≡ 1, instead of assigning any redshift parameterizations to it, and constrain the cosmological information preferred by fgas data along with supernova observations. We adopt a new binning method in the reduction of the Union2 data, in order to minimize the statistical errors. Four data sets of X-ray gas mass fraction, which are reported by Allen et al. (two samples), LaRoque et al. and Ettori et al., are analyzed in detail in the context of two theoretical models of fgas. The results from the analysis of Allen et al.’s samples demonstrate the feasibility of our method. It is found that the preferred cosmology by LaRoque et al.’s sample is consistent with its reference cosmology within the 1σ confidence level. However, for Ettori et al.’s fgas sample, the inconsistency can reach more than a 3σ confidence level and this dataset shows special preference to an ΩΛ = 0 cosmology.

Keywords X-rays: galaxies: clusters — cosmology: distance scale — galaxies: clus- ters: general — cosmology: observations — supernovae: general

null